Textual Analysis of Previous Student Work - Mr Bojangles by Robbie Williams

This music video is narrative based, and tells of "Charlie Chaplin" and his trip to the future. I thought the use of the colour change from black and white to full colour, was used very effectively, and creates a nice contrast, and definable difference between the two times, helping the narrative run more fluently. Many long shots are used to emphasise the space around "Charlie Chaplin" and also to make the most of the wide range of locations featured, in an appropriate way rather than using the shots, just for the sake of it. Also the 360 degree shot of "Charlie Chaplin" is very well attempted, if a little unsteady, but shows the impact of London, and how different and confusing it is to "Charlie". By including the "Charlie Chaplin" character, the video has a much more relaxed and fun feel to it, which mirrors the song itself, so adheres to one of Goodwin's Six. There is also a link between the lyrics and visuals, as Robbie Williams sings "Mr Bojangles, come back, and dance" Charlie Chaplin begins to make his way home, again a feature of Goodwin's Six. There is also an intertextual reference, as "Chaplin" finds and sits by a large statue of himself, from the future. Not only does this incorporate another of Goodwin's Six, but it is also quite a post modern idea, and creates a sense of self-reflexivity as "Charlie" can see what an influence he will eventually have.

Strengths

Very original idea and a good, strong narrative that fits with the song.

Good use of varied locations.

Convincing acting which enhances the believability of the narrative.

Interesting floor level shots of "Charlie Chaplin"chasing his hat and when he throws the hat over the camera allowing for a visual match transition.

Weaknesses

Sound quality isn’t as clears as it could be and lets it down slightly. However being uploaded to You Tube may have reduced the quality.

Some steady shots are a little unsteady, slightly wobbly.

The low lit shot at 1.49 seconds is a little too dark, losing the detail and lessening the professional feel of the video.

In my video I will endeavour to keep all my shots as steady as is necessary and will re-film certain shots in order to get them as steady as possible, if they are not. I will also be very conscious of the lighting I will use in my video and try to keep it as consistent as possible, for continuity; as well as make sure I don't lose any detail in any shots from them not being properly lit.